X-ray Fluorescence Analysis of Lead in Tin Plating Using Theoretical Intensity of Scattered X-rays - Analysis of RoHS Regulated Elements by Energy Dispersive X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometer (EDX)

Significance of the Topic

This study addresses the critical need for reliable screening of RoHS-regulated hazardous elements such as lead in thin metallic films used in electronic components. Accurate quantitation of these elements is essential for compliance verification, environmental safety, and consumer protection, especially as device miniaturization and complex geometries challenge conventional analytical methods.

Goals and Overview of the Study

The primary aim was to develop and validate a rapid EDX-based approach to quantify lead in tin plating while compensating for film thickness effects. A tin-plated copper resistor terminal served as the model sample. Two analytical strategies were combined: a calibration curve for lead concentration and a fundamental parameter (FP) method to determine plating thickness. The approach was extended to various electrical parts to confirm general applicability.

Methodology and Instrumentation

• Energy Dispersive X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometer (EDX-720): Used for initial calibration and screening. Shape effects were corrected using Rh Kα Rayleigh scattering.
• Energy Dispersive Micro X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometer (µEDX-1200): Enabled micro-area analysis (50 µm diameter) to cross-check results with minimal shape influence.

Main Results and Discussion

• Lead Calibration Curve: Standard MBH solder samples produced a linear relationship between Pb Lβ1 intensity ratio (to Rh Kα scattering) and concentration, yielding a base quantitation of 313.4 ppm for the resistor terminal.
• Plating Thickness Measurement: Using the FP method with pure tin and copper standards, the tin layer thickness was determined as 9.1 µm.
• Thickness Correction Factor: A theoretical intensity model derived a correction factor of 0.87 for 9.1 µm tin films, adjusting the lead concentration to 272.7 ppm.
• Validation: µEDX-1200 measurements averaged 269 ppm, corroborating the corrected EDX-720 result. Multiple part types (display terminals, diode terminals, connectors, washers, IC and spark-killer terminals) showed consistent agreement between EDX and µEDX values after correction.

Benefits and Practical Applications of the Method

• Streamlined Compliance Testing: Enables rapid screening of numerous and irregularly shaped electronic parts without extensive sample preparation.
• Versatility: Applicable to various plated materials (tin, nickel, zinc) and elements (lead, cadmium, chromium) with pre-tabulated correction factors.
• Cost-Effectiveness: Reduces reliance on more time-consuming techniques (e.g., ICP) for initial screening.

Future Trends and Applications

Advancements may include automated integration of thickness correction algorithms within EDX instrumentation, expansion of FP databases for additional plating/substrate combinations, and coupling with machine learning to predict correction factors. Miniaturized or portable µEDX units could further support in-field compliance checks.

Conclusion

The combined calibration-curve and FP methodology demonstrated accurate quantitation of lead in thin plating on complex shapes. Film thickness correction based on theoretical scattered X-ray intensities is validated against micro-XRF data and offers an efficient route for RoHS compliance screening across diverse electronic components.

References

1. M. Nishino, “Bunseki,” 6, 286 (2007)
2. C10G-E016D, “RoHS/ELV Complying with European Chemical Substance Regulations,” Shimadzu Corp., 2009
3. H. Ochi et al., “Shimadzu Review,” 60, 137 (2003)
4. H. Ochi et al., “Shimadzu Review,” 66, 257 (2009)
5. IEC62321 Annex D, “Screening by X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometry,” 2008
6. T. Shiraiwa, N. Fujino, “Jpn. J. Appl. Phys.,” 5, 886 (1966)
7. H. Ochi, H. Okashita, “Shimadzu Review,” 45, 51 (1988)
8. H. Ochi, S. Watanabe, “Advances in X-Ray Chemical Analysis,” 37, 45 (2006)
9. H. Ochi, S. Watanabe, H. Nakamura, “X-ray Spectrom.,” 37, 245 (2008)