Robust Elemental Analysis of Sodium-Ion Battery Cathode Materials Using ICP-OES

Significance of the Topic

The rapid expansion of energy storage for grid and electric vehicles has increased demand for cost-effective battery chemistries. Sodium-ion batteries offer a sustainable alternative to lithium-ion systems due to abundant sodium resources, lower raw material costs, and improved safety at ambient conditions. Ensuring chemical purity of cathode materials is critical to optimize electrochemical performance, prevent capacity fade, and support emerging quality standards.

Objectives and Overview of the Study

This study aimed to develop and validate a robust ICP-OES method for determining trace elemental impurities in three representative sodium-ion battery cathode materials: a Prussian blue analog, sodium iron phosphate, and sodium manganese oxide. The objectives included establishing detection limits, assessing accuracy via spike recovery, and demonstrating long-term stability for routine quality control.

Methodology and Instrumentation

Samples were digested by single-step microwave treatment in aqua regia prior to analysis. Elemental quantification was performed on an Agilent 5800 Vertical Dual View ICP-OES equipped with an SPS 4 autosampler, SeaSpray nebulizer, cyclonic spray chamber, and dual-view torch. Key software tools included

• IntelliQuant Screening for rapid semiquantitative profiling and wavelength selection
• IntelliQuant semiquantitative analysis for in-run quality control
• Fitted Background Correction (FBC) and Fast Automated Curve-fitting Technique (FACT) for automated background and interference handling

Internal standards (Y and Rb) corrected matrix-induced signal variations. Calibration covered ranges from 0.05 to 500 mg/L depending on the analyte.

Main Results and Discussion

• Calibration linearity exceeded r²>0.999 for all 30 analytes with <10% calibration error.
• Method detection limits ranged from sub-µg/L to tens of µg/L in sodium-rich matrices.
• Spike recoveries for all elements in three cathode matrices were within 90–110%, confirming method accuracy.
• A 10-hour sequence with 410 measurements maintained QC recoveries within ±10% and RSDs below 3% without recalibration.
• In-run IntelliQuant monitoring provided additional assurance against spectral interferences.

Benefits and Practical Applications of the Method

• Comprehensive quality control of precursor materials in sodium-ion battery production
• Support for compliance with emerging standards on cathode purity
• Reduced re-analysis through automated background correction and QC screening
• High throughput and long-term stability for routine laboratory operations

Future Trends and Possibilities of Use

As sodium-ion technology matures, regulatory requirements for impurity limits will become more stringent. Future developments may include expanded elemental speciation, integration of online process monitoring, and coupling with complementary techniques such as mass spectrometry for isotopic or molecular-level insights. Enhanced automation and machine learning in data processing will further improve efficiency.

Conclusion

The validated ICP-OES method on the Agilent 5800 VDV platform delivers precise, accurate, and high-throughput elemental analysis of sodium-ion battery cathode materials. Advanced software tools ensure robust background correction, interference management, and in-run quality control, making this approach well suited for battery material quality assurance and research laboratories.

References

1. Lithium-Ion Battery Market Size By Chemistry (LFP, LCO, LTO, NMC, NCA, LMO), By Component (Cathode, Anode, Separators, Electrolytes, Aluminum Foil, Copper Foil, Others), By Application (Industrial, Automotive, Consumer Electronics, Energy Storage), 2023–2032. GMI Insights, accessed December 2023.
2. Walter M, Kovalenko MV, Kravchyk KV. Challenges and benefits of post-lithium-ion batteries. New J Chem 2020;44(5):1677–1683.
3. Fleischmann J, et al. Battery 2030: Resilient, sustainable, and circular. McKinsey & Company report 2023.
4. Tapia-Ruiz N, et al. 2021 roadmap for sodium-ion batteries. J Phys Energy 2021;3:031503.
5. Mosallanejad B, et al. Cycling degradation and safety issues in sodium-ion batteries: Promises of electrolyte additives. J Electroanal Chem 2021;895:115505.
6. Velumani D, Bansal A. Thermal behavior of lithium- and sodium-ion batteries: A review. Energy & Fuels 2022;36(23):14000–14029.
7. Scott A. Sodium comes to the battery world. C&EN 2022;100(19).
8. Rudola A, et al. Reviewing the safe shipping of lithium-ion and sodium-ion cells: A materials chemistry perspective. Energy Materials Advances 2021.
9. Kang L. Hina Battery becomes first battery maker to put sodium-ion batteries in EVs in China. CnEVPost February 2023.
10. Nguyen TP, Kim IT. Recent advances in sodium-ion batteries: Cathode materials. Materials 2023;16(21):6869.
11. Tang W, et al. High-performance NaFePO₄ formed by aqueous ion-exchange: mechanism for advanced sodium-ion batteries. J Mater Chem A 2016;4(13):4882–4892.
12. Wang DY, et al. Recent advances of organometallic complexes for rechargeable batteries. Coord Chem Rev 2021;429:213650.
13. Zuo W, et al. Layered oxide cathodes for sodium-ion batteries: Storage mechanism, electrochemistry, and techno-economics. Acc Chem Res 2023;56(3):284–296.
14. Agilent Technologies. Agilent ICP Expert Software: Powerful software with smart tools for ICP-OES. Pub. 5994-1517EN.
15. Agilent Technologies. Agilent IntelliQuant Screening: Smarter and quicker semiquantitative ICP-OES analysis. Pub. 5994-1518EN.
16. Agilent Technologies. Agilent IntelliQuant Software: For greater sample insight and simplified method development. Pub. 5994-1516EN.
17. Agilent Technologies. ICP-OES background and interference removal accurate. Easy. Reliable. Pub. 5991-8452EN.
18. Agilent Technologies. Fitted Background Correction: Fast, accurate, and fully automated background correction. Pub. 5991-4836EN.
19. Agilent Technologies. Real-time spectral correction of complex samples using FACT spectral deconvolution software. Pub. 5991-4837EN.
20. Agilent Technologies. Innovative freeform optical design improves ICP-OES speed and analytical performance. Pub. 5994-5891EN.